Modular aircraft: Flexibility to save costs

Modular aircraft and cabins allow air­lines to respond more quickly to dif­fer­ent pas­sen­ger needs and market situations, making air transport more efficient.

02.2019 | Text: Denis Dilba

Text:
Denis Dilba holds a degree in mechatronics, is a graduate of the German School of Journalism, and founded the “Substanz” digital science magazine. He writes articles about a wide variety of technical and business themes.

The trans­porta­tion of goods in stan­dard­ized con­tain­ers, which were in­vent­ed in 1956 by U.S. trans­port en­tre­pre­neur Mal­com McLean, is con­sid­ered one of the most im­por­tant de­vel­op­ments in lo­gis­tics. Once loaded in­to the met­al box­es, car­go can be car­ried over large dis­tances on var­i­ous modes of trans­port, in­clud­ing trucks, trains and ships. Group­ing car­go in this way does away with time-con­sum­ing un­load­ing and re­load­ing and re­duces ware­hous­ing and lay­time costs in ports. This rev­o­lu­tion­ized goods trans­porta­tion on land and at sea. Now, Clau­dio Leonar­di from the Swiss Fed­er­al In­sti­tute of Tech­nol­o­gy Lau­sanne (EPFL) hopes to achieve a sim­i­lar rev­o­lu­tion in air car­go with his Clip-Air con­cept. The re­searcher has been work­ing on this fu­tur­is­tic air­craft study since 2009.

Video: Combined transportation: Train and plane Article with video

Combined transportation: Train and plane

The Clip-Air concept could bring air travel directly to city centers and industrial locations—with far-reaching consequences for our mobility concepts. To the video ...

Flying-wing aircraft with flexible-use container capsules

Clip-Air con­sists of two el­e­ments: First, there is the fly­ing part: a fly­ing-wing air­craft. And then there are cap­sules that stack in a sim­i­lar way to con­tain­ers on a ship and sim­ply dock to the fly­ing mod­ule. De­pend­ing on the con­fig­u­ra­tion se­lect­ed, they can then serve as a cab­in or a car­go hold. What makes Clip-Air in­ge­nious is that the cap­sules can al­so be used as rail­cars. “This would ef­fec­tive­ly let us bring air­craft right in­to the cen­ters of cities,” says EPFL re­searcher Leonar­di. Pas­sen­gers would board their “flight” at the train sta­tion. The train would then bring the cab­in mod­ules to the air­port, where they would be cou­pled to the fly­ing-wing unit. There would be no need for pas­sen­gers to trans­fer to the flight or board it sep­a­rate­ly; they could sim­ply sit back and re­lax. This would make stress as peo­ple rush to their gate a thing of the past, and air­ports and air­lines would al­so ben­e­fit from the time saved. An­oth­er ad­van­tage of the mod­u­lar air­craft con­cept is that op­er­a­tors could re­spond flex­i­bly to de­mand, adds Leonar­di. “For ex­am­ple, you could at­tach on­ly sec­ond-class or on­ly first-class mod­ules.” De­pend­ing on the book­ings for a giv­en flight con­nec­tion, this would avoid fly­ing with an emp­ty first-class cab­in, which is a waste of space and of fu­el. It would al­so rep­re­sent an in­no­va­tion in rail trans­port, en­abling freight and pas­sen­ger mod­ules to be trans­port­ed at the same time.

The EPFL sci­en­tists have cal­cu­lat­ed that with a wingspan of 60 me­ters, the air­craft would have a range of up to 4,000 kilo­me­ters. Un­der the main wing struc­ture, it could car­ry three mod­ules mea­sur­ing about 30 me­ters in length and four me­ters in di­am­e­ter—each of which cor­re­sponds rough­ly to an Air­bus A320 in size. This of­fers space to car­ry ei­ther three sets of 150 pas­sen­gers or a large vol­ume of car­go. Re­plac­ing one of the three car­go mod­ules with an ad­di­tion­al, mo­bile fu­el tank would al­so in­crease the range of Clip-Air, says Leonar­di, which is an added bonus. If and when the con­cept will be­come re­al­i­ty, how­ev­er, is still very much an open ques­tion. Leonar­di hopes, of course, that Clip-Air will take off one day, but he un­der­stands that the pro­ject is a long-term en­deav­or.

Video: Link & Fly by Akka Technologies Article with video

Link & Fly by Akka Technologies

A cabin or cargo hold capsule can be docked to the flying module as needed. This approach offers many advantages. To the video ...

Coupling poses a technical challenge

Kay Plöt­ner, Head of Eco­nom­ics and Trans­porta­tion at the Bauhaus Luft­fahrt re­search in­sti­tute, doubts whether such a mod­u­lar air­craft con­cept will ever get off the ground. And the sci­en­tist knows the sub­ject mat­ter well: In 2013, col­lab­o­rat­ing with de­sign stu­dents from the Uni­ver­si­ty of Glas­gow, he and his Bauhaus Luft­fahrt col­leagues al­so de­vel­oped a mod­u­lar air­craft study that com­bined rail and air trans­port.

“Where such sys­tems of­ten fall down is that the air­craft them­selves be­come too heavy and in­ef­fi­cient,” says Plöt­ner. The cou­pling mech­a­nism for the mod­ules has to be de­signed in such a way as to be se­cure. As the forces are con­cen­trat­ed on a few points, a more sol­id de­sign is re­quired, which ul­ti­mate­ly adds more weight. An­oth­er com­pli­ca­tion is that the com­plex­i­ty at air­ports would in­crease un­less the in­fra­struc­ture un­der­goes sig­nif­i­cant over­haul. “This means you’d have to make very cost­ly al­ter­ations to air­ports and in some cas­es to train sta­tions as well.” These prob­lems al­so ap­ply to the cur­rent Link & Fly con­cept from the French tech­nol­o­gy con­sult­ing com­pa­ny Ak­ka Tech­nolo­gies, which in­volves cou­pling just one train mod­ule with a fly­ing mod­ule.

The Bauhaus Luft­fahrt ex­pert reck­ons that the mod­u­lar Trans­pose con­cept from the Air­bus re­search unit A3 based in Sil­i­con Val­ley has a some­what greater chance of suc­cess. At the start of 2017, the team led by pro­ject di­rec­tor Ja­son Chua pre­sent­ed a con­cept for mod­u­lar air­craft cab­ins.

Clip-Air aircraft compared to conventional commercial aircraft

Clip-Air aircraft compared to conventional commercial aircraft

Flexible aircraft The individual modules are docked under the main wing structure of a flying-wing aircraft. It can fit up to three modules—each of which corresponds roughly to the size of an Airbus A320.

Adaptable cells

These mo­bile mod­ules are de­signed to be switched in and out at air­ports with­in a mat­ter of min­utes, which would al­low air­lines to adapt their air­craft to the in­di­vid­ual needs of pas­sen­gers on cer­tain routes in the fu­ture. Ac­cord­ing to A3, be­tween ten and 14 of these cab­in com­part­ments would fit in­side an A330. Chua’s idea is to have mod­ules con­tain­ing fa­cil­i­ties like kids’ play ar­eas and child­care for fam­i­lies, fly­ing con­fer­ence rooms, gyms and cafés. “This added val­ue for cus­tomers should, of course, be an in­cen­tive for them to pay a lit­tle ex­tra,” says Plöt­ner. Some­thing sim­i­lar ex­ist­ed once in the past: spe­cial mod­ules were de­signed for the low­er deck of the Air­bus A340-600. These mod­ules housed the re­strooms for econ­o­my class, the main kitchen and a re­lax­ation room for flight at­ten­dants—al­beit at the ex­pense of the us­able car­go space. More­over, they were per­ma­nent­ly in­stalled and not ex­change­able, as they are in the A3 con­cept. “The­o­ret­i­cal­ly, the Air­bus idea would be fea­si­ble,” says Plöt­ner.

(strich:Versatile) The Clip-Air concept is based on interchangeable modules of different sizes for carrying freight, passengers or fuel, depending on demand. Hover over the image for a bigger view

Versatile The Clip-Air concept is based on interchangeable modules of different sizes for carrying freight, passengers or fuel, depending on demand.

aeroreport_1_vielfaeltiger_nutzen

Versatile The Clip-Air concept is based on interchangeable modules of different sizes for carrying freight, passengers or fuel, depending on demand.

(strich:Travel in comfort) Clip-Air’s passenger modules can be transferred straight from the airfield to the train station while passengers sit back and relax. Hover over the image for a bigger view

Travel in comfort Clip-Air’s passenger modules can be transferred straight from the airfield to the train station while passengers sit back and relax.

aeroreport_2_komfortables-reisen

Travel in comfort Clip-Air’s passenger modules can be transferred straight from the airfield to the train station while passengers sit back and relax.

Aircraft from a pool

Whether the de­mand is there and the mod­u­lar cab­ins guar­an­tee high­er or at least the same rev­enue, how­ev­er, is some­thing that Plöt­ner and oth­er ex­perts are doubt­ful about. In ad­di­tion, the air­lines would have to car­ry out new weight cal­cu­la­tions for each new con­fig­u­ra­tion of the cab­in. Chua is con­fi­dent nonethe­less that a Trans­pose pro­to­type will take off in just a few years’ time. A3 is al­ready in con­tact with the Fed­er­al Avi­a­tion Ad­min­is­tra­tion re­gard­ing ap­proval, he adds. Plöt­ner and his col­leagues are more op­ti­mistic about an idea that al­so takes in­to ac­count the up­com­ing in­di­vid­u­al­iza­tion trend in air trans­port, but does not re­ly on mod­u­lar con­cepts: “My re­sponse to the de­mand for flex­i­bil­i­ty in the fu­ture is to have a large pool of air­craft with dif­fer­ent con­fig­u­ra­tions avail­able at an air­port, so the air­line can sim­ply de­cide based on their book­ing sit­u­a­tion which one they want to use,” says the ex­pert. “We call this an air­craft shar­ing mod­el.” In this sce­nario, the air­craft would no longer be­long to the air­lines, but to a large leas­ing com­pa­ny, for ex­am­ple.

“We be­lieve this mod­el would in­volve rel­a­tive­ly lit­tle al­ter­ation to the trans­port sys­tem—you wouldn’t have to make any ma­jor changes to the jets or the air­ports,” says Plöt­ner. The on­ly rad­i­cal thing about this is the way it changes plan­ning, op­er­a­tions and crew sched­ul­ing for the air­craft serv­ing in the net­work. If all air­lines world­wide agreed to take part and, for ex­am­ple, all Boe­ing 737 air­craft and Air­bus A320 jets were com­bined in one shar­ing pool, the Bauhaus Luft­fahrt re­searchers cal­cu­late that be­tween 20 and 25 per­cent few­er air­craft would be re­quired. “This would leave trans­port ca­pac­i­ty un­changed but open the door to low­er op­er­at­ing costs,” says Plöt­ner. In ad­di­tion, the glob­al air­craft shar­ing mod­el large­ly avoids the cost­ly tran­si­tion to mod­u­lar hard­ware. “Wher­ev­er pos­si­ble, we use things that can be changed via soft­ware: light, dig­i­tal la­bels and dis­plays.” So, in the same way you in­stall an app on a smart­phone, in the fu­ture you might be able to switch a leased air­craft from Lufthansa to easy­Jet with the sim­ple tap of a but­ton.

MTU Newsletter
MTU Newsletter

Receive regular updates on excellent service and top technology “made by MTU” with our newsletter, which also features a range of topics from the wider world of aviation.

You may also be interested in these articles:

How aircraft are painted

11.2016 | Paint is important—and not just for the external appearance of an aircraft. Paintwork has many functions, which include protecting aircraft against corrosion and lengthening their service lives. In the future, it will even improve environmental performance.

Better flight connections

11.2016 | Dealing with the increase in worldwide air traffic between urban centers calls for new, quieter aircraft and more efficient airports. Big data applications also help get passengers and luggage to their destination more quickly.

High-bypass engines of the future

02.2018 | In the EU technology program ENOVAL, MTU Aero Engines is developing innovative low-pressure turbine technology for the engines of tomorrow. Very high bypass ratios of up to 16:1 will make engines quieter and more efficient, with lower emissions.